Contractor selection for Tropicana/I-15 project raises some questions

2 years ago 152

The contractor that could transportation retired the Tropicana Avenue/Interstate 15 interchange task was selected past week, but not without immoderate controversy.

At the authorities Board of Transportation meeting, Kiewit Infrastructure West was chosen arsenic the evident champion worth for the project, beating retired Ames Construction. That was contempt Kiewit’s connection carrying a $305 cardinal terms tag — $41 cardinal much than Ames’ $264 cardinal bid.

Earlier this year, the Nevada Department of Transportation estimated the task would outgo astir $270 million, up from archetypal outgo estimates of $230 million. The summation was mostly owed to adding repaving enactment connected I-15 betwixt Warm Springs Road and Hacienda Avenue and rising operation costs, according to Lynnette Russell, NDOT adjunct task manager. That repaving enactment was already successful the works but was added into the project’s scope.

NDOT and Kiewit adjacent volition conscionable and corroborate the declaration up of its last support astatine adjacent month’s Board of Transportation meeting.

Project details

The project’s scope includes I-15 betwixt Russell and Flamingo roads and Tropicana betwixt Las Vegas Boulevard and Valley View Boulevard.

Tropicana implicit I-15 is deteriorating owed to unanticipated postulation volume, truthful the capableness needs to beryllium accrued connected the freeway ramps and the span implicit the interstate, Russell said.

Plans telephone for reconstructing the interchange, creating a diamond on-ramp and off-ramp configuration and a flyover astatine Tropicana.

Dean Martin Drive volition beryllium reconfigured to spell underneath the Tropicana freeway ramps, removing a postulation awesome astatine the intersection adjacent the In-N-Out restaurant. Circular roads volition beryllium added to support entree to the northwest and southwest quadrants.

Sidewalks connected Tropicana implicit I-15 volition beryllium expanded from 5 feet to 10 feet, and a caller pedestrian walkway volition beryllium constructed from the northbound broadside of Tropicana down to Frank Sinatra Drive, adding entree to T-Mobile Arena.

High occupancy driblet lanes are besides planned to beryllium added to and from Harmon Avenue, which would beryllium located connected the southbound broadside of the bridge.

With I-15 and Tropicana starring to the southbound extremity of the Strip, T-Mobile Arena and Allegiant Stadium, mitigation measures are successful spot to guarantee postulation volition beryllium capable to question successful and retired of the country during construction.

The scoring process

Each institution that bid connected the task was graded connected 2 areas: price, which accounted for 60 retired of the 100 disposable points; and method connection evaluation, oregon however the institution would transportation retired the project, which was worthy 40 points.

Ames received a 24.4 retired of 40 connected the method connection valuation portion Kiewet got a 38.28.

On price, Ames’ cheaper outgo scored a cleanable 60, portion Kiewet’s rated a 51.9. As a result, Kiewet netted a 90.18 wide score, besting Ames’ 84.4.

Outgoing Lt. Gov. Kate Marshall questioned however Ames, a institution utilized by NDOT successful the past, could people truthful debased connected the method side, noting the stark outgo differences successful the 2 proposals.

“We’re talking superior wealth present and I was authorities treasurer, truthful adjacent I deliberation that’s superior money,” Marshall said during the meeting. “It seems to maine that successful bid to get Kiewet to beryllium the archetypal bidder you had to technically measurement Ames’ connection very, very, precise debased and it surprises me. It surprises maine due to the fact that Ames is simply a reputable entity present successful Nevada that has done design-build projects before.”

Nick Johnson, NDOT task manager, noted that Ames has done a batch of enactment with the section and has done a bully occupation successful those instances. But this connection wasn’t arsenic beardown arsenic Kiewit’s, helium said.

“The details, I can’t spell into due to the fact that they’re confidential astatine the infinitesimal but careless we worked with our squad to spell done that (selection process),” Johnson said during the meeting. “It’s their connection that they submitted and those are the scores that came up. But I deliberation successful the lawsuit of Kiewit, different large company, too, and the squad scored them high.”

Las Vegas Paving was disqualified arsenic a contender for the declaration earlier the last stages of the reappraisal process.

“During this process … it was determined that LVP’s connection was not compliant with the requirements of the RFP (request for proposal) and the method provisions and that they failed astatine slightest 1 of the pass/fail criteria,” Russell said successful an email. “As a result, they were notified that they had been disqualified from further information and were not eligible for grant of the contract.”

Bill Wellman, part manager for Las Vegas Paving, spoke during nationalist remark and questioned the terms associated with Kiewet’s bid, noting their connection was listed astatine $228 million.

“This is not astir our disqualification,” Wellman said during the meeting. “This is astir spending an further $80 cardinal of taxpayers’ money.”

Contact Mick Akers astatine makers@reviewjournal.com oregon 702-387-2920. Follow @mickakers connected Twitter. Send questions and comments to roadwarrior@reviewjournal.com.

Read Entire Article